Inevitability – Let the Dominoes Fall…

Some things seem to be inevitable. The other day my daughter knocked over a box of cereal. As I cleaned up a significant volume of crunchy breakfasty goodness, it struck me how many things had come into play to ensure this particularly messy outcome:

  1. It is the end of the school year and I have caved somewhat and am buying the children ‘special cereal’.  (Yes mother guilt here… usually they eat toast and porridge).
  2. Typically I would only buy a small box, but this week the large box was on special…
  3. Because the contents of the large box wouldn’t fit in the plastic cereal container I put the whole box on the table.
  4. I put the box next to my six-year-old daughter, on the edge of the table (you can see where this is going).
  5. I thought to myself, ‘that box is a bit close to the edge‘.
  6. My next thought was, ‘no – she’ll be right’...
  7. My daughter knocks the box with her elbow.
  8. She catches the bottom of the box as it falls.
  9. Because she is holding the bottom of the box the considerable contents inside continue to rain down all over the floor…
  10. I do that slow-mo “Nooooo” as I wade through the crunchy tide in a futile attempt to stem the flow.
  11. I have to clean up the floor because it’s a bit sticky and crunchy and bits have bounced everywhere…

You might think the moral of this story is: Don’t buy the cereal. But as a writer, the moral is actually:  Don’t overlook the power of a good set up.

If you know your character needs to stumble, or encounter setbacks – work out ways of making sure they fall into your clever trap their circumstances are such that the only way forward is into conflict. This can be either internal or external, but it can be enough to give your story real momentum.

The Plotting Tool.

The movie Signs is an excellent example of how to make the most of the set up. The beginning of the movie establishes some strange and random character idiosyncrasies that end up being the key to saving lives and defeating the ill-informed alien invaders. As a technique it’s fairly simple.  Identify your desired outcome and work backwards from there.

In my WIP, The Fall of the Kings, one of the important plot points turns on one of the characters helping another. It’s an unlikely scenario because Jae (the helper), belongs to a group typically shunned by the general populace. Tobias (in need of help) is not only of the general populace, but is also part of the religious order Jae is particularly leery of. Yet although it’s unlikely she would go out of her way to save him – it is imperative to the story that she does. So I needed to lay some groundwork. This started with questions:

  • What would cause her to risk her life (and the life of others) to save this man she doesn’t know? Answer: She wouldn’t for any stranger. There would need to be some sort of connection between them.
  • What could he do that would impact her enough to a) recognise him again; and b) cause her to act. Answer: He would show her he was different – had a different attitude towards her people. Maybe show her unexpected kindness.
  • Where would their paths cross before the major plot point?

You get the idea. When all the elements line up, Jae and Tobias are set for their own adventure – one that seemed destined from the beginning.

Inevitability is not the same as Predictability.

The difference between inevitability and predictability is one of perspective. Predictability is knowing something is going to happen; inevitability is looking back and realising it couldn’t have happened any other way.

No one wants to write predictable stories. The trick is not to be so obvious when you line things up that the reader knows exactly what’s going to happen. Use a light touch. There is plenty of room for nuance, subtlety and surprise. If  all goes well the story will feel real – rather than manipulated.

Set-up with Care.

We’re told as writers not to include anything superfluous in a story – i.e. don’t go giving Frodo the light of Earendil’s star and then not have any opportunity to use it. But also don’t give Frodo the light and then have him use it in the very next scene either. Let him carry it around for a while, and preferably leave it to the very last moment to realise it might be of particular significance against a creature steeped in darkness. Even better for tension if the reader has had time to forget about it too. Unless you’re writing a pantomime you don’t want your audience yelling use the light.

Reader Pay Off.

In my personal experience (as reader or viewer), I love it when things all of a sudden fall into place.

Take the classic line in Star Wars – The Empire Strikes Back, where Darth Vader says: “I am your father.” What can I say – one of the best reveals ever!

Or in a smaller way in The Name of the Wind by the amazing Patrick Rothfuss, the main character Kvothe breaks a string on his lute and has no way of replacing it. So every time a string breaks he teaches himself to play with those that remain. Although this is appropriate to the place in the story – it really comes into its own much later when someone tries to sabotage him by breaking a lute string at an important concert. Honestly as a reader I literally started jumping up and down…

How about you? As a reader what are some of your favourite set-ups? As a writer do you actively set things up to fall like a line of dominoes? I love to hear from you…


16 thoughts on “Inevitability – Let the Dominoes Fall…

  1. Love the cereal bit. Why is it we never listen to that voice, the one that tells us how bad an idea a certain action is? That other voice always pipes up, “Ah, it’ll be fine!” Not.

    It’s too early for my brain to think of my favorite set-up, but I do know that I’ve often thought, “Yeah! Take that!” 🙂

      1. Characters are funny, they run the spectrum from simple to psychotic. As we take the time to develop the character and hone their reactions, it is a true exercise of patience on our part. And a huge leap of faith.

  2. I am OBSESSED with inevitability in the stories I read or write. To me this is the one thing that sets aside awesome books from all the others. One of my favourite example is not a Fantasy book, its “A Prayer for Owen Meany” by John Irving: every single thing that happens to the main character (however insignificant) turns out to be incredibly important for the outcome of the story. I love the movie “Signs” as well, another good example of this domino effect. And the latest example I’ve come across is “The Thief” by Megan Whalen Turner. The final twist is set up from the beginning, and it’s great to be surprised at the end and to want to re-read the whole book “to know how she did it”…

    1. Ah – I have just bought the Thief – so will look forward to the ending! Another book I just loved was ‘The Miracles of Santa Fico’ by D.L. Smith. In that book the characters spend a lot of time trying to manufacture miracles – but things never work out as planned. The result however is miraculous and a superb example of intelligent plotting!

  3. i think the most popular set up has to be the romantic boy meets girl falls in love overcomes some problem and lives happily ever after. Although that’s not my favorite story line.
    My favorite story is when the girl kick prince charming in the fruit and tells him she better off alone. Also I think that you know who I’m married to so there is a certain amount of planning is involved when one of us wants some thing (or gets board and wants to wind the other up)

    1. Thanks ReGi – that’s really nice. I’m so glad you enjoy the blog – I love hearing from you too! PS We finally have brilliant sunshine (always touch and go in the run up to Christmas) – thinking of you in the very festive wintery north!

  4. I think inevitability is best accomplished (subtly) when you have properly outlined (milestoned, waypointed, whatever). You covered that pretty well previously. If you know where the story is going, you can drop subtle hints along the way – a word or phrase at most – and readers can re-read and find the beauty and subtlety woven throughout.

    1. I love it as a reader when you finally see the reveal and all of a sudden the story takes on a whole new level of meaning because it does all tie up. I do plan, but my friend who has a completely different approach / style has been reading me a WIP serial style over the past few years and is writing the end now. It has just had the most amazing twist ending which none of us saw coming (including her – she is a pantster) but it ties up everything that goes before. Hugely satisfying.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s